OYsters & Lobsters In Maine

I love Maine. It’s as simple as that. Its pristine waters, its rocky coastline, its charming (and salty) way of life.

The world moves at half the pace and with twice as much sincerity up here. B and I trekked as far north as Acadia National Park and as far seaward as Chebeague Island. we found our dream wedding venue, put a dent in the lobster population, and of course, enjoyed some of the state’s best oysters.

Mad about Maine

In my opinion, Maine is one of the last "frontiers" of the East. With just a population of 1.3 million (2010), it is set among the top 10 least populated states in the US. Maine's unspoiled nature is just as fertile as it is beautiful. They are reputed with having some of the best tasting oysters on the east coast. I can personally vouch for that, as you'll read about later. It's no secret either. A couple thousand years ago, Native Americans were all about the wild oysters from Damariscotta River—and they left their tab behind for all to see. Today, most of Maine's most prominent oyster farms are stationed along the Damariscotta, including Glidden Point, Pemaquid, and Cape Blue. If you're really lucky, you can also find yourself a wild Belon!

Maine Oyster Tasting Notes

On this trip, we were able to get our hands on some fantastic local favorites. Before hopping on the ferry to Chebeague Island, I headed over to buy oysters from the Harbor Fish Market, a reputable seafood market that attracts both locals and visitors. The selection and knowledge of the fishmongers was indeed extensive. I picked up four different varieties: three from Maine, one from Massachusetts.

John’s River from South Bristol, Maine

Flavor: 9 | Salinity: 7 | Sweetness: 6 | Texture: Plump, slightly chewy, meaty This deliciously complex oysters was by far everyone's favorite. It had a great balance of brininess, sweetness, and earthiness.

Winterpoint from Mill Cove, Maine

Flavor: 8 | Salinity: 8 | Sweetness: 4 | Texture: Soft, very meaty The largest of the bunch, but also the most straightforward in taste. Winterpoints were difficult to shuck (due to size) -- I actually had to use force!

Damariscotta from Damariscotta River, Maine

Flavor: 5 | Salinity: 5 | Sweetness: 3 | Texture: Slightly meaty, a bit thin Simple sea flavor with a little bit of earthiness, relatively clean finish.

Duxbury from Duxbury Bay, Massachusetts

Flavor: 7 | Salinity: 8 | Sweetness: 5 | Texture: Thin, soft, tender These oysters had a rather pungent undertone, relatively briny, with a lingering salty finish.

The four dozen oysters disappeared quickly amongst the eight of us. Some opted to drizzle a little lemon juice on theirs, but I encouraged everyone to try at least one naked. That's really the only true way to fully appreciate the fresh and vibrant taste of Maine. The more fresh the oyster, the less garnish you need.

My very first lobster bake experience

Of course, that's not all that we ate during the weekend. This season, there was a glut of lobster. While having excess is certainly better than the opposite, the reality of this surplus doesn't help everyone. While we giddily scarfed down lobster wherever we went, we learned that lobstermen up and down the Maine coast were challenged to sell their excess product at a fair price. Talk about being caught between a claw and a hard place. To think of it, I didn't really see any dramatic price cuts in NYC for lobster either, with exception to the $6.99/lb sale at Citarella's. (We've seen it as high as $16.99/lb there!)

On a more positive note, I experienced my first authentic lobster bake on the island. Family friends of our friend's family hosted the most quintessential afternoon lobster bake and party that I've ever been to. Their charming plot of island comes with access to the water, a lush lawn, a breathtaking view of the southwest, and an insanely gorgeous summer house. Mental note: that's what I want in 20 years.

I learned that true lobster bakes aren’t for the lazy. The kids were all put to work immediately to gather up seaweed from the beach. At least two dozen lobsters were tossed into the bed of sea greens, along with a sack of onions, potatoes, a mattress of sweet corn, and two cartons of fresh eggs. After two and a half cocktails, the food was ready to eat. I had never tasted such succulent, tender lobster before. What was even more surprising was that onion!?! Who knew that onion could be so juicy and sweet?

This was my first Maine island vacation, but there will be many more to come! We also were able to lock down our wedding venue earlier in the trip, which I will leave as a relative secret until our website is up.